

I’ve been playing Minecraft my entire life, and I played Minecraft Dungeons on day one. I played the first game a lot, and while I had issues with its initial state, I was ultimately very pleased with how they refined it. As you might expect, I was extremely excited for Minecraft Dungeons II, but honestly wasn’t sure what to expect. Part of me worried the sequel would be a rehash of the original with a jump button and a new story, which would have felt somewhat disappointing.
After playing through the main campaign, I can say it feels very distinct from the first game, and I think a lot of that sprang from the decision to make an interconnected, almost open world, which meant movement couldn’t be such a pain like it was in the first. I would bet money that a central design philosophy of its sequel was, put simply, “make it fast.”
The first thing I noticed was that they removed the slowdown after you roll. This always felt clunky to me, and I was pleasantly surprised to see I could roll through the game without worrying about it hurting my mobility, especially with the wide-open areas you had to navigate and retread. A movement skill like a roll should feel like a movement skill, and it absolutely did now. Jumping opened a whole new design avenue for parkour challenges, and I was thrilled to see Mojang add a long-jump mechanic. It’s simple and doesn’t have its own dedicated animation, but if you jump as you come out of a roll, you carry the momentum forward and jump slightly farther. Being able to skip certain challenges (and one difficult ambush in a cave) with a well-placed long jump felt nice. Combined with the removal of fall damage, this let Mojang design more intricate terrain that felt satisfying to navigate.


The second thing I noticed was a change to how artifacts work. You can equip three artifacts that act like secondary abilities and use them at any time, such as a speed boost, a quiver of fire arrows, or a healing circle. In Dungeons II, they dramatically shortened the cooldown periods on these artifacts. The Death Cap Mushroom, for example, had an average cooldown of 30 seconds in Dungeons but four seconds in Dungeons 2. The tradeoff is that every artifact now costs soul, which you gain by attacking enemies, not from pickups dropped by defeated enemies (making soul gathering much faster). They wanted you to use your artifacts a lot more often, which (combined with the faster attack speed of most weapons) helped make the combat feel smooth, fast, and very satisfying… when they decided to work.
There’s a really frustrating glitch I kept running into where artifacts sometimes think they’re still on cooldown even when they aren’t, and the only way to fix it is to replace the artifact in your inventory. This creates a horrible situation where it’s obvious that the game wants you to use artifacts all of the time because of the shorter cooldowns. But you don’t want to use them, because there’s always the risk of them getting locked, with literally the only way to unlock them being to manually reset them in the inventory and let you get beat up by enemies you can’t see. This, as you might expect, is not very fun.
When the game works, though, it really works. It’s finely polished, looks gorgeous, and plays very well. But this one glitch creates so much anxiety around a central mechanic of the game that, for those less judicious with artifact usage and less on the ball with regularly resetting them during downtime, it can make the game almost unplayable – and you shouldn’t need to be those things in the first place. That’s the whole point of reducing artifact cooldowns. It’s a huge oversight, and I don’t understand how Mojang’s playtesters missed it before this point.


The world is interconnected, but calling it “open” just yet feels like a stretch. A lot of the map is off-limits, which clearly makes room for the DLC expansions they’re already advertising. It’s a neat way to introduce new areas in DLCs without resorting to island realms like in the original, but it feels kind of lame to have 60 percent of the map visually locked off because of the promise of future paid expansions. That said, the developed areas are visually distinct, and the ambiance is beautiful. The new Sift dimension is especially gorgeous, on the other side of the portal in the Ancient City. I worried the Sift would blend together and become boring, but they took a lot of care to create distinct biomes for it, too. It’s obvious that a lot of care went into the game’s visual and environmental design.
With the world being interconnected and intentionally designed, I was worried that there wouldn’t be procedural dungeons anymore, but there are – although they aren’t tied to the main campaign. Dungeons are scattered throughout each area, all labeled “Dungeon” on the map. I barely engaged with them at all because they aren’t required. The main draw of the dungeons is the reward of enchanted books, which you can use infinitely to enchant your gear, although there are other ways to get enchanted books. Personally, I preferred the enchanting system from the first game, at least after the addition of the blacksmith and the ability to re-roll enchantments; it feels like a nice balance of gambling and control through veto, which I really enjoyed. The new system with enchanted books feels like an overcorrection into absolute control, which I’m sure will be welcomed by most players, but is less engaging for me – it feels less like carefully designing a build and investing in a specific item, and more like selecting one perk in a menu full of them. Once you have a set of enchantments you like, you have no reason to branch out.
This, combined with only being able to enchant items at the enchanter NPC and instantly upgrading gear to your current item level at the blacksmith, disincentivizes experimentation. Finding a better weapon with different possible enchants no longer inspires new builds, and you no longer have any reason to test weapons that outpace your old one in stats. A more reasonable compromise, in my eyes, would have been to keep the enchantment system from the first game, but allow players to discover empty books in dungeons. The enchanter could then remove enchants from your items and put them on the book, which you could spend later to add to an item. This would have given you fine control by letting you “slot in” your enchants without relying on luck, while still encouraging experimentation through random available enchants. I honestly expected them to feature a system like that, and I was disappointed they didn’t.


The story is interesting but feels more like a showcase of the Sift dimension than anything more substantial on its own, which is par for the course with recent Minecraft spinoff games. The addition of cutscenes that interrupt the game for story beats, along with the ability to talk to certain NPCs, gave the story room for more depth.
However, only one part of the main campaign stood out to me: a noble act of sacrifice by an unnamed NPC who received no honors. There was a lot of potential in the idea of industrial colonization exploiting the natives and resources of a new land, which is what the plot revolves around, but in practice there isn’t much depth beyond “Illager bad, beat them up.”
To top this off, the main antagonists, the Illager High Council, went underutilized – the final boss of the main campaign wasn’t even against them. Rather than a 1v3 climactic battle, it was a single-phase fight against a super soldier soul-powered monstrosity they created, which hits like a truck and killed me a handful of times, but I was still able to shred through it in seconds using a build I (almost accidentally) put together while barely engaging with the dungeons of Minecraft Dungeons.


When working as intended, Minecraft Dungeons II runs smoothly and plays far better than the first game. The environments are beautiful and thoughtfully designed, and new mechanics to deliver a deeper story were very welcome. However, the grand finale was anticlimactic, the new enchantment system feels like it discourages build experimentation, the titular dungeons are completely optional, and a glaring oversight in the artifact cooldown system flies in the face of the faster-paced combat Mojang was going for.
After the obvious expansions are released and some bugs are fixed, some of these problems may be resolved. For now, though, even though the gameplay is far superior to the first game, they ultimately butchered the central gameplay loop of build experimentation and dungeon diving.

