Starsand Island is ranked in the 51st percentile of games scored on OpenCritic.
Starsand Island is an enjoyable although not perfect addition to the cosy life sim genre. It has plenty to do and collect and its flexible building system will keep some players glued for hours. If you’re a fan of cosy farming mechanics, collecting bugs and fish, and developing relationships with NPCs then there’s plenty here to like. The games pretty graphics are also going to be a big draw for anime fans.
Read full review
Starsand Island’s 1.0 release is a massive leap forward from its Early Access foundation. The addition of 4-player co-op, Steam Workshop mod support, rich NPC interactions, and sweeping quality of life upgrades make it one of the most versatile life sims available.
Read full review
Cozy sandbox life sim experience with plenty of content on Nintendo Switch 2
Read full review
Starsand Island surprised me with just how deep of a life sim it is. There are still many bugs that need to be ironed out but they didn’t stop me from sinking countless hours into its delightful world as it does a lot of things exceptionally well. 🏝️
Read full review
Starsand Island is a game I am personally going to be getting lost in for the foreseeable future.
Read full review
Starsand Island is a decent farming sim, however the Nintendo Switch 2 version is filled with so many bugs, it needs an industrial-grade insecticide to make it playable.
Read full review
Starsand Island gets an incredibly begrudging recommendation, with a list of asterisks next to it. It’s a surprisingly fun core experience, and it implements a ton of features that I wish other life simulation games had with great-feeling gameplay. The way everything interlinks is done really well, and there’s tons to unlock. Sadly, it’s let down by the minimal content around the characters and an incredible number of bugs and other issues to the point that it feels like it should have never left early access before being dealt with. Yet despite all the problems it has, it’s just enjoyable enough in many ways to somewhat forgive the issues and keep playing for hours on end.
Read full review
Starsand Island is a solid game worth checking out if you love relaxing farming and skill-building sim games. The story and character development aren’t terribly deep, but there’s plenty of potential for the future. Give the developers a little more time to patch things up and you’ll find Starsand Island well worth your time exploring.
Read full review