The company didn’t show the fame of the Roblox mark in Australia when the domain was registered.

Roblox, the massive online gaming platform, has lost a cybersquatting claim filed against an Australian man over the domain roblox.io.
Jake Arnold registered the domain name, along with several similar domains, in 2015 for a planned business. He provided evidence of these plans and even registered a business name at the time.
A World Intellectual Property Organization panel unanimously agreed that Roblox failed to show the domain was registered or used in bad faith, as the .io dispute policy requires.
At the time of registration, Roblox’s fame was nascent, particularly in Australia. The domain was never used.
One panelist, Tony Willoughby, found that this was an abusive filing and a case of reverse domain name hijacking.
Willoughby noted that the initial filing might not have been in bad faith. But once the registrar identified the registrant, Roblox had the opportunity to withdraw or amend its arguments. Instead, it merely amended the complaint to name the registrant.
Roblox was represented by experienced counsel at Winston Taylor International LLP and, he said, should have provided evidence of Roblox’s fame in Australia in 2015 but failed to do so. Willoughby wrote:
Thus, the Complainant had the opportunity of reviewing the original Complaint to see how this new information impacted it and to bolster it as necessary. The Respondent’s email address (via the Respondent’s domain name in that address) gave the Complainant a very simple method of learning more about the Respondent. As my colleagues observe, the Complainant is represented by an experienced counsel and that represented parties are often held to a higher standard when addressing RDNH…The homepage on the Complainant’s representative counsel’s website cites four areas of speciality one of which is a paragraph headed “Strategic IP” reading:
“Create the protection you need for business-critical assets and defend them when it counts. As one of the largest and most highly regarded transatlantic IP practices, we bring unmatched depth, experience and creativity to every IP matter.”
With that level of support the Complainant must have been advised that the original Complaint had no chance of success unless it was boosted by evidence to show at the very least that in 2015 when the disputed domain name was registered the Respondent was likely to have been aware of the existence of the Complainant. The Complainant would also have been advised that bare unsupported assertions are not enough. Allegations of bad faith must be supported by the best evidence a complainant can readily muster. On reviewing the Complaint and having Australia as the key area to address and seeing that the supporting evidence as to reputation and goodwill back in 2015 goes no further than the United States, the Complainant would have realised that its principal allegations were unsupported, resting solely on bare assertions…
Some panelists give complainants a break when they couldn’t have known the facts before the registrant was revealed. But they have an opportunity to withdraw the complaint, and they should when the registrant’s details change the calculus.
