Close Menu
Stardew Valley

Who did you marry your first time and do you still stand by it?


Who did you marry your first time and do you still stand by it?

by Starobin-Lestine

View 48 Comments

48 Comments

  1. Ok-Bread2991 on

    Harvey. I’ve been with everyone and I’ll always come back to Harvey! I imagine him as Pedro with glasses. So fine… 🥵

  2. Commercial_Egg525 on

    I’m playing for the first time – I married Leah.. well I’ll divorce her soon for Haley or Abigail 🫣

  3. bonepalaceballetx on

    Sebastian. I marry him every play through and the only time I haven’t married him was with an NPC from a mod….then I divorce them and marry Seb again.

  4. that_plant_mom on

    I’ve only married Harvey, but Krobus was my roommate when I was completely against marriage in my first ever save lol

  5. Don-Quioxte on

    Started with Leah. Certainly don’t regret the choice but I’d say she’s probably in 3rd now behind penny and Emily.

  6. libraryoracle on

    I’ve always married abigail! I lean towards people with a more goth/alt sense of style IRL so I think it makes sense 😀 

  9. VeganCheesecake666 on

    Haley, i like that she gets nicer. And i stand by it. I shall branch out tho

  11. bakersdozing on

    I married Elliott first, then Krobus was my “roommate” for the longest time. I married Harvey on my new playthrough, but Krobus is my fave.

  12. spunky_monkey_45 on

    I married shane because I was impatient and wanted to see what happened when you married someone.

    He didnt do much and left a mess so I divorced him then he got mean again and wouldnt speak to me. Nit sure if you can be friends with him after divorce.

  14. Kaitorubel on

    I fell in love with Sam when I first played ages ago. I thought when ever I played again maybe I’d try someone else. But when I finally played again I missed Sam too much and had to go with him again. Now I don’t think I could ever go for anyone else.

  15. Realistic-Loss3276 on

    Bassy but couldn’t choose between him, Sam, alex and Shane so I make a separate save just for them

  16. petuniya00 on

    Elliot was my first. I went for him ironically bc he looked like a romance novel cover… but he grew on me. Would marry again. But interested in Leah for next go. I know it’s a game but a lot of the characters feel like teens and I feel like a creep. 😆 Might consider Harvey for a play through one day.

  19. Lil_Witch5 on

    I married Penny for my first playthrough because she reminded me of myself. And I still love her character however ive been wanting to marry everyone before I pick my favorite, but i only marry one noc person playthrough so ive not yet married her again.

  20. doc_baggs on

    Penny, but the past couple of saves I’ve married Haley. Apparently I can’t resist a mean girl. 🤷‍♀️

  21. ChemistAloe770 on

    Married seb first, then Shane (regretted that immediately) and now I marry Leah all the time

  22. BAKspin_91 on

    First time was Emily, and having now dated everyone but Penny on the girls side I think she is my number 1 (Haley is a close second, followed by Maru).

  29. espae on

    Emily, ‘cause she was nice. I was kind of achievement farming so I needed someone to have two kids with and so I just married the older nice woman.

    I didn’t really like having a housemate in the game, though. I like being a weird loner farmhand. I don’t think I’d marry anyone again.

  30. Fun-Wait-3497 on

    Sebastian but over time ive grown obsessed with Shane so no i dont stand by Seb sadly but Shane is my new pick for every playthrough

  33. Bethanydk419 on

    Abigail still my favorite married her twice Emily once and still single on year 4 this go. Last 2 were perfection achieved

  34. AlpharioInteries on

    From my first playthrough, till now, I went

    Abigail

    Emily (One I regret)

    Penny

    Leah (Current one).

    Honestly, from the story-telling pov, I still believe Abigail is best out of these, although closely followed by Penny.

  40. shelob_spider on

    Shane. i did divorce him in my main save (biggest regret),married Elliot (second biggest regret) divorced him, and then married (also currently married) to Harvey, who i have also been loving!!!! The other guys seem too young so i feel uncomfortable marrying them. Shane is definitely my favorite, but harvey is a very close second.

  45. killerpuppytails on

    Married Abigail 1st, then Leah, then Shane, and I’m now married to Harvey.

    I haven’t divorced anyone yet; these are all new saves. Next I’ll try Maru, Sam and Krobus, but my fave so far is Leah.

  46. Diligent_Studio_601 on

    Abigail, and yes I still stand by it. She’s always been my favorite. 🥰