I really thought that the guy who bred a special type of chicken would like it. He has a picture of a chicken hanging above his bed and sells the cutest chicken decal at the desert festival. I really thought he'd look at it and go "Wow, how did you know I love chickens?" but he hated it

This also happened when I gave Evelyn flour for her baking and energy potion to George this is definitely not a game where you can guess what gifts they'll like based on their interests or situations.

by Key-Cricket-2797

8 Comments

  1. I’m lazy. Almost everyone really digs coffee, I just carry it around and give it to all the coffee lovers I run into during my day

  2. My sister and I are playing on a multiplayer farm and when she did that exact same thing, I went “haha how’d you fumble that”

    I then gave Haley a golden coconut and she absolutely HATED it lmao. Needless to say, I can’t make fun of my sister anymore for giving Shane a chicken statue and getting bashed for it

  3. chicagoantisocial on

    Oh bro I gave Demetrius a mushroom on his birthday because he started the mushroom cave on my farm and is always talking about how he likes fungi especially in autumn, he reacted sooooo badly and got super angry at me. I was shocked

  4. RegularTemporary2707 on

    Actually i played some mod that made him like the statue and hates beer (after the heart event of course)

  5. YourIngrownTo3nail on

    Also, dont give that Strange Bun to him even though he said to share one if youre making it with an uncharacteristic “hehe” at the end of his letter.

  6. Hot-Bicycle5798 on

    I usually carry a stack of diamonds and give everybody. I do t start to be friend people until later in the game.